OLIVE OIL MAYO

Feb 12, 2024 | Sides and Sauces

MAKES 1 ½ cups

Lemony, light, silky, and luxurious, this mayo makes just about everything better. Indulge with a dollop of grilled meat, transform it into creamy salad dressing in a flash, or stir it into a can of tuna for instant salad. Mix up a batch every week in the blender or food processor to rediscover creamy salads and sauces.

INGREDIENTS

• 1 large egg
• 2 tablespoons lemon juice
• 1/4 cup plus 1 cup light-tasting olive oil (not extra-virgin!)
• 1/2 teaspoon dry mustard
• 1/2 teaspoon salt

DIRECTIONS

1. Science! The magic of mayo is that it’s an emulsion: the oil and egg plus lemon create a colloid. You don’t need to understand all the physics, but you do need to bring all of your ingredients to room temperature.

2. In a blender or food processor, break the egg and add the lemon juice. Put the lid on your appliance and allow the egg and lemon juice to come to room temperature together for at least 30 minutes and up to 2 hours.

3. When the egg and lemon juice are room temperature, add the mustard, salt, and 1/4 cup oil to the canister. Blend on medium until the ingredients are combined. Now the exciting part begins. Your mission is to incorporate the remaining 1 cup of oil by pouring very, very slowly. You want the skinniest drizzle you can manage; this takes about 2 to 3 minutes. Breathe. Relax. Sing to yourself.

4. If you’re using a blender, you’ll hear the pitch change as the liquid begins to form the emulsion. Eventually, the substance inside the blender will resemble traditional mayonnaise, only far more beautiful. Do not lose your nerve and consider dumping! Continue to drizzle. Slowly.

5. When all of the oil is incorporated, revel in your triumph and transfer the mayo to a container with a lid. Mark a calendar with your egg expiration date; that’s when your mayo expires, too.

You know how you could do that?

Use cider vinegar instead of lemon juice for a new twist.
Stir in a few chopped, pickled jalapeños for a kick of heat

More Paleo Recipes

A person in a knit sweater holds a bowl of homemade Apple and Pear Sauce topped with cinnamon, with fresh apples and pears in the background.

Apple and Pear Sauce

There is something so comforting about a simple, fruit-forward snack that isn’t loaded with refined sugars. I recently found myself craving a healthy treat that would satisfy my sweet tooth without the guilt, which led me to whip up this incredibly smooth Apple…

Bowl of homemade Paleo Hoisin Sauce with a whisk, surrounded by ingredients like almond butter and garlic on a wooden table.

Hoisin Sauce

If you’ve been missing that signature sweet and savory kick in your stir-fries, this homemade Paleo Hoisin Sauce is going to be a total game-changer for your kitchen. We all know the store-bought versions are usually packed with refined sugars and additives that just…

Close-up of a woman's hands holding a glass jar filled with dark, sugar-free Paleo Worcestershire sauce substitute.

Worcestershire Sauce

Let’s be real—giving up your favorite condiments is one of the hardest parts of cleaning up your diet. I used to miss that distinct, savory tang in my marinades, but this Paleo Worcestershire Sauce changed the game for me. It delivers all that deep, complex umami…

A person in a knit sweater holds a bowl of homemade Apple and Pear Sauce topped with cinnamon, with fresh apples and pears in the background.

Apple and Pear Sauce

There is something so comforting about a simple, fruit-forward snack that isn’t loaded with refined sugars. I recently found myself craving a healthy treat that would satisfy my sweet tooth without the guilt, which led me to whip up this incredibly smooth Apple…

Bowl of homemade Paleo Hoisin Sauce with a whisk, surrounded by ingredients like almond butter and garlic on a wooden table.

Hoisin Sauce

If you’ve been missing that signature sweet and savory kick in your stir-fries, this homemade Paleo Hoisin Sauce is going to be a total game-changer for your kitchen. We all know the store-bought versions are usually packed with refined sugars and additives that just…

Close-up of a woman's hands holding a glass jar filled with dark, sugar-free Paleo Worcestershire sauce substitute.

Worcestershire Sauce

Let’s be real—giving up your favorite condiments is one of the hardest parts of cleaning up your diet. I used to miss that distinct, savory tang in my marinades, but this Paleo Worcestershire Sauce changed the game for me. It delivers all that deep, complex umami…

Glass jar of homemade Paleo lacto-fermented horseradish paste sitting on a wooden table next to fresh horseradish roots and a grater.

Lacto-Fermented Horseradish

If you know me, you know I love adding a serious flavor kick to my meals, and this Paleo Lacto-Fermented Horseradish is my absolute favorite way to do it. Honestly, it tastes so much fresher than the store-bought stuff, and because it’s fermented, it’s packed…