CARAMEL SAUCE

Apr 4, 2025 | Sides and Sauces

Makes 1 cup

This versatile sauce is amazingly fun to make (science in action!) and useful on quite a few recipes. We use it to make Candied Nuts, our Samoa Cake Balls, and inside our homemade chocolate candies. It’s delicious to drizzle it on special treats like ice cream.

Making caramel isn’t as hard as it might seem, but it takes patience and lots and lots of stirring. Get your big muscle arm out and prepare to watch bubbles grow!

INGREDIENTS

• ½ C honey
• ½ C maple syrup
• ½ tsp baking soda

INSTRUCTIONS AND HOW KIDS CAN HELP

1. Warm large sauce pan over medium heat, add honey and maple syrup to warm pan—mixture should gently bubble, but if it begins to immediately boil and brown it has burned and you should start over.
2. Once gentle bubbles begin to form, turn heat to medium low; have little hands continuously stir (to prevent burning).
3. Mixture will bubble and potentially expand over edge of pot, if that happens, remove from heat and stir; return to heat once bubbles subside.
4. Once sauce has thickened and the color has darkened (about 10 minutes), remove from heat to add baking soda.
5. Whisk in baking soda thoroughly and continue to stir as it starts to expand and bubble; return to medium heat for 2-3 minutes. Whisk constantly until sauce has become a thick, rich, bubbly sauce that does not reduce when moved off of heat.
6. Remove from heat and let cool, stirring occasionally–sauce will reincorporate to a thick caramel consistency.
7. Serve and use warmed (heat in microwave or on stovetop).
8. Store in an airtight container for several months in refrigerator.

More Paleo Recipes

Bowl of homemade Paleo Hoisin Sauce with a whisk, surrounded by ingredients like almond butter and garlic on a wooden table.

Hoisin Sauce

If you’ve been missing that signature sweet and savory kick in your stir-fries, this homemade Paleo Hoisin Sauce is going to be a total game-changer for your kitchen. We all know the store-bought versions are usually packed with refined sugars and additives that just…

Close-up of a woman's hands holding a glass jar filled with dark, sugar-free Paleo Worcestershire sauce substitute.

Worcestershire Sauce

Let’s be real—giving up your favorite condiments is one of the hardest parts of cleaning up your diet. I used to miss that distinct, savory tang in my marinades, but this Paleo Worcestershire Sauce changed the game for me. It delivers all that deep, complex umami…

Glass jar of homemade Paleo lacto-fermented horseradish paste sitting on a wooden table next to fresh horseradish roots and a grater.

Lacto-Fermented Horseradish

If you know me, you know I love adding a serious flavor kick to my meals, and this Paleo Lacto-Fermented Horseradish is my absolute favorite way to do it. Honestly, it tastes so much fresher than the store-bought stuff, and because it’s fermented, it’s packed…

Bowl of homemade Paleo Hoisin Sauce with a whisk, surrounded by ingredients like almond butter and garlic on a wooden table.

Hoisin Sauce

If you’ve been missing that signature sweet and savory kick in your stir-fries, this homemade Paleo Hoisin Sauce is going to be a total game-changer for your kitchen. We all know the store-bought versions are usually packed with refined sugars and additives that just…

Close-up of a woman's hands holding a glass jar filled with dark, sugar-free Paleo Worcestershire sauce substitute.

Worcestershire Sauce

Let’s be real—giving up your favorite condiments is one of the hardest parts of cleaning up your diet. I used to miss that distinct, savory tang in my marinades, but this Paleo Worcestershire Sauce changed the game for me. It delivers all that deep, complex umami…

Glass jar of homemade Paleo lacto-fermented horseradish paste sitting on a wooden table next to fresh horseradish roots and a grater.

Lacto-Fermented Horseradish

If you know me, you know I love adding a serious flavor kick to my meals, and this Paleo Lacto-Fermented Horseradish is my absolute favorite way to do it. Honestly, it tastes so much fresher than the store-bought stuff, and because it’s fermented, it’s packed…

Pouring white wine over sliced red chili peppers and sea salt in a mason jar to begin the fermentation process.

Louisiana-Style Fermented Hot Pepper Sauce

If you’re anything like me, a meal just isn’t complete without a little kick of heat. But finding a store-bought bottle that strictly fits a clean lifestyle can be tricky. That’s exactly why I fell in love with making this Paleo Louisiana-Style Fermented Hot Pepper…